The Cheapest Beginner Robo-Advisor Changes With the Balance

Fidelity Go charges no advisory fee below $25,000. At $25,000, its published 0.35% fee begins and the annual advisory cost becomes $87.50.

Betterment creates the opposite small-account problem. Without at least $200 in qualifying monthly recurring deposits, an account below $24,000 pays $5 a month. That is $60 a year at either $1,000 or $10,000.

Estimated annual advisory cost by account balance
Provider$1,000$10,000$25,000$100,000
Fidelity Go $0 $0 $87.50 $350
Vanguard Digital Advisor About $1.50 to $1.60 About $15 to $16 About $37.50 to $40 About $150 to $160
Wealthfront $2.50 $25 $62.50 $250
Betterment $60 $60 $62.50 $250
E*TRADE Core Portfolios $3 $30 $75 $300
Merrill Guided Investing $4.50 $45 $112.50 $450
Schwab Intelligent Portfolios Below minimum $0 $0 $0

These are published program-fee estimates, not total investing costs. Betterment assumes no qualifying recurring deposit. Schwab charges no advisory fee, but the required cash allocation and fund expenses still matter.

Where a Beginner Should Start With Robo-Advisors

The first choice is not the brand. It is the kind of help the account needs to provide.

  • Start with Fidelity Go when the balance is below $25,000 and direct advisory cost is the deciding factor.
  • Start with Vanguard when a low published percentage fee and index-focused approach matter most.
  • Start with Wealthfront when taxable-account automation and tax tools matter more than human help.
  • Start with E*TRADE when a $500 minimum and an established brokerage relationship fit the account.
  • Consider Schwab when the balance clears $5,000 and the required cash allocation makes sense for the plan.
  • Consider Merrill when Bank of America and Merrill integration is worth a higher published fee.

Betterment can fit a beginner who will make qualifying recurring deposits. Without them, the flat monthly fee deserves its own calculation before the account is funded.

Merrill, Schwab, and E*TRADE Change More Than the Fee

Merrill Guided Investing, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios and E*TRADE Core Portfolios connect automated management to a larger brokerage relationship. That can simplify transfers and support. It can also make several accounts easier to keep together.

The tradeoff is not hidden. Merrill charges 0.45% without an advisor. E*TRADE charges 0.30%. Schwab charges no direct advisory fee, but every portfolio includes cash and Schwab earns revenue from that allocation.