The Decision Comes Down to the Relationship
| Decision | Merrill Edge | Schwab |
|---|---|---|
| Standard online trading | $0 online stock and ETF trades | $0 online listed stock and ETF trades |
| Options contract charge | $0.65 per contract | $0.65 per contract |
| Banking relationship | Eligible Bank of America accounts and BofA Rewards | Optional linked Schwab Bank Investor Checking |
| Service model | Phone, online chat for account opening, and appointments | 24-hour phone support and more than 400 branches |
| Full outgoing transfer | $49.95 | $50 |
The standard trade prices are nearly identical. The useful difference is how the brokerage fits the rest of your financial life and how you want help when something goes wrong.
The Headline Trading Costs Are Almost the Same
Merrill Edge and Schwab both list no minimum for a standard self-directed brokerage account. Both charge no commission for eligible online stock and ETF trades, and both charge $0.65 per options contract.
That does not make every transaction free. Broker-assisted trades, mutual funds, wires, options, fixed income, foreign securities, account transfers, and specialty services can carry separate charges. Check the exact transaction you expect to use instead of treating the zero-dollar headline as the whole price.
Merrill Is Strongest Inside a Bank of America Household
Eligible Bank of America and Merrill accounts can share one online relationship, and money can move immediately between eligible banking and brokerage accounts. Eligible combined balances can also help a household qualify for BofA Rewards benefits.
Schwab answers the banking question differently. A Schwab One brokerage account can link to Schwab Bank Investor Checking, which adds checking, a debit card, bill pay, and worldwide ATM fee rebates. The better answer depends on whether you already use Bank of America or want the brokerage to bring its own linked checking account.
Schwab Makes Round-the-Clock Help the Clearer Promise
Schwab lists U.S.-based customer support 24 hours a day and more than 400 local branches. That is the cleaner answer for an investor who expects to call outside normal business hours or wants a dedicated brokerage branch nearby.
Merrill provides phone support, online chat for account-opening questions, and appointment scheduling with a Merrill Financial Solutions Advisor. Its in-person advantage is tied closely to the Bank of America relationship rather than a standalone brokerage branch network.
The Full Transfer Fees Are Nearly Identical
Merrill lists a $49.95 full outgoing account transfer charge for standard self-directed brokerage accounts. Schwab lists $50 for a full outgoing account transfer. Partial transfers are listed at no charge by both providers under the current standard terms.
A fifty-dollar exit fee should not decide a long-term brokerage relationship by itself. It belongs in the comparison because the cost appears when the relationship has already stopped working.
Make the Decision in Three Checks
- List the Bank of America or Schwab Bank features you would actually use during an ordinary month.
- Choose the help model you want when a transfer, trade, card, or login problem cannot wait.
- Price the specific mutual funds, options, wires, assisted trades, and transfer services you expect to use.
Keep Managed Investing as a Separate Decision
This page compares self-directed brokerage accounts. Merrill Guided Investing and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios are managed programs with different fees, minimums, portfolio rules, and conflicts.
If you want the provider to build and rebalance the portfolio, use the managed-account comparison instead of carrying the self-directed result into a different product.